Read a Preview

You don’t need to read this book straight through.

Start anywhere.

Stay with a question.

Here's one place to begin:

Kathy was retiring.

Her room was already half-packed, the kind of half-packed that feels heavier than full. Posters were coming down. Desk drawers were emptied. A whole career was being quietly folded into cardboard boxes. Midmorning light slanted across the room, catching the edges of stacked papers and leaving long shadows over the student desks.

I was her assistant principal at the time – technically her evaluator – but that day none of that mattered much. She had spent years in that room. I had walked in near the end of that story, and part of me recognized that I was sitting in the presence of something I didn’t yet fully understand.

“I still can’t believe you’re retiring,” I said.

“Me neither,” she smiled. “But I know it’s time.”

I sat down in one of the student desks. The room felt different without kids in it – quieter, lighter. As if it were holding its breath.

“So… what was it all for?” I asked. “What’s the point of all this?”

She didn’t hesitate.

“I want students to learn,” she said. “And I want them to think for themselves.”

That sounded right. It still sounds right.

But even then, it didn’t feel finished.

“How do we make that happen?” I asked. “Is there more to it than just learning and thinking?”

We talked for a long time after that – about curiosity, frustration, and the kids who surprised us. About the lessons that fell flat and the ones that somehow caught fire. About the strange mixture of intention and mystery that lives inside teaching.

Somewhere in that conversation, without trying to, we started circling a question. I didn’t know it yet, but it would follow me out of that room and into almost everything that came next.

I didn’t find that question in a framework or a book. I stumbled into it that morning in Kathy’s classroom, and once it arrived, it didn’t leave. It followed me into classrooms, into post-observation conferences, into moments when I wasn’t proud of how I had shown up – and into moments when I was.

Over time it became a kind of mirror – not a checklist, not a goal, but a way of noticing.

When I think back on my own teaching – and later on my work alongside other teachers – I can trace almost everything I care about back to that moment.

Not because the question gives me answers.

Because it keeps asking something of me.

It asks something when I’m frustrated.
It asks something when I’m hopeful.
It asks something when I realize I’ve been going through the motions.

And sometimes it sits there in silence, just as it did in Kathy’s empty room, waiting for me to notice what I’m doing and why.

This book grows out of that question and everything it stirred in me. Not because I’ve figured it out – but because I haven’t.

I keep circling the same tension:

How much of learning lives in what we teach,
and how much lives in how we show up?

How much of a classroom does the curriculum build,
and how much do the small, human moments that never make it into lesson plans contribute?

I don’t have clean answers to those questions. I only know they keep shaping the way I see students, lessons, and myself.

Maybe they’ll start doing that for you too.

The question born in Kathy’s empty classroom?

How will I behave with my students and design my lessons to increase the probability students will learn, wonder about, and have passion for my content?

Pause and Reflect

Pause for a moment with the question that grew out of this chapter.

Essential Question
How will I behave with my students and design my lessons to increase the probability students will learn, wonder about, and have passion for my content?

You don’t need to answer this right away.
You don’t need to write anything down.

Just notice what happens when you let the question sit with you for a minute.

What part of this question feels most alive for you right now – your behavior, your lesson design, your students’ learning, their wonder, or their passion?

When have you felt most proud of the way you showed up for students?

If your classroom had a kind of north star, what would you hope it was quietly pointing toward?